The Holy Gospel for this past Sunday in the three-year lectionary, St. Matthew 16:21-28, is perhaps the best and clearest example of the contrast between a “theology of glory” and the “theology of the cross,” such as Dr. Luther highlighted in the Heidelberg Disputation (1518) and in various other writings. There could hardly be a starker confrontation between the thinking of our fallen flesh with its ideas of “glory” and the “foolish” wisdom of God embodied in the Cross and Passion of our dear Lord Jesus Christ.
In the preceding Holy Gospel, from the prior Sunday, by the grace of God Simon Peter made his great confession that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of the Living God. Upon the ministry of that confession the Lord promised that He would build His Church, so that even the gates of Hades would not prevail against her; which is to say that neither death nor the grave would be able to contain those who belong to the Body and Bride of Christ Jesus. The Office of the Keys, as well, which Jesus bestows upon St. Peter as an Apostle and a Minister of the Gospel, derives from and depends upon the victory of Christ Jesus over sin, death, the devil, and hell; for His sacrificial death upon the Cross has atoned for the sins of the world and defeated the power of death, and His mighty Resurrection from the dead has opened the Kingdom of Heaven to all who believe and are baptized in His Name.
It was not by his own flesh and blood – not by his own wisdom, reason, or strength – that St. Peter was able to recognize and confess that Jesus is the incarnate Son of God and the Lord’s Anointed (Christos). But where did the Father graciously reveal this to Peter? At the Baptism of our Lord in the Jordan River, when He was openly declared to be the beloved and well-pleasing Son and anointed by the Holy Spirit in the form of a dove. What is more, the Baptism of our Lord was also the onset of His Cross and Passion, as well as the promise of His Resurrection from the dead. In submitting Himself to St. John’s Baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins, Jesus took the sins of all the people upon Himself and committed Himself to bearing those sins in His Body to the Cross, to be crucified, put to death, and buried, as surely as He was submerged in the waters of the Jordan. And as He arose and emerged from out of the water to an open heaven and the blessing of His Father, so did He receive the pledge that His Father would also raise Him from the dead on the Third Day. Thus was it necessary for the Christ to suffer these things and thereby enter into His glory in fulfillment of the Scriptures of the Law and the Prophets.
Of course, it was directly from the waters of His Baptism that the Lord Jesus was immediately driven by the Spirit into the wilderness, there to be tempted by Satan in our stead, as our merciful and great High Priest. At the heart of that temptation, the devil called into question His divine Sonship, the very thing that His God and Father had just declared from heaven. What is more, the devil urged this beloved Son to avoid suffering and to seek the praise and glory of the world. And it is an echo of that same Satanic delusion and deception that Simon Peter fell prey to in his presumptuous rebuke of the Lord Jesus.
Upon the great confession Jesus began to catechize His disciples in what it meant for Him to be the Christ, the incarnate Son of the Living God: that He must go to Jerusalem, suffer many things, be put to death, and then rise again on the Third Day. At that point, Peter demonstrated that he did not yet understand what he had only just confessed! His good intentions notwithstanding, his attempt to keep the Lord Jesus from the Cross and suffering was a Satanic error and a denial of all that was necessary. His human thinking – his human wisdom, flesh and blood – could not grasp the true divine Glory that would be obtained, manifested, and bestowed upon us by the ways and means of the Cross. For that reason, Jesus needed to rebuke Simon Peter, call him to repentance, and put him back in line. In telling him to “get behind Me,” the Lord reminds the disciple that he must follow and learn from Him, and certainly not the other way around. In due time, St. Peter would learn to know and love the glory of the Cross, as he was counted worthy to share in that suffering for the sake of the Gospel.
For us it is relatively easy to affirm the Cross of our Lord Jesus Christ, especially as we know the whole story with 20/20 hindsight, and we know the Easter Gospel of the Resurrection, as well, which makes for a nice package deal. Even so, our own fallen flesh, our sinful hearts and foolish minds, recoil no less than Simon Peter’s at the prospect of the Cross and suffering in our bodies, lives, and circumstances on earth. We, too, would surely prefer to avoid all that and enter straight into the glories of the Resurrection, such as we imagine and envision them to be. That is still the way that man thinks, and not the way that God thinks. Hence, the Lord catechizes His disciples – both then and now – to take up the Cross and follow Him, to live with Him, to learn from Him, to die with Him, and so also to rise with Him in glory at the last.
He lays the Cross upon us in this body and life in a wide variety of ways, and for a variety of purposes. There are times when it is the discipline of the Father for His beloved child, to guard and protect from every evil and from harmful dangers to body and soul, and to call the erring to repentance. Then there are those times when the Cross we bear and carry is simply the burden of our calling and station in life, whereby we emulate and echo the Cross of Christ, who bore our griefs and carried all our sorrows in His own Body, even unto death. On other occasions we share the glory of His suffering when we bear the reproach of His Name and the ridicule of His Word for honoring His Law and trusting His Gospel.
In all these things, we are more than conquerors through Him who loves us, who has borne the Cross and blazed the trail before us. Not only that, but He is with us on our journey, sustaining us under the Cross and bringing us through death into life. That is what He does! And this is a significant aspect of what it was that Dr. Luther recognized and understood about the “theology of the Cross.” Namely, that the Lord is with us and deals with us under the very opposite of anything we would ever expect. He’s not to be found in those things that the world and our senses perceive to be “great” and “glorious,” but He is present and at work in many ways that the world and our fallen flesh despise and disregard as evil. The key, of course, is not that we go looking for suffering and death – the early church recognized that danger and strongly warned against it – but instead, we direct our days and our deeds and measure all things by the Word of God in Christ Jesus, even when that Word is at odds with our human reason and every expectation of our hearts and minds and past experience and worldly wisdom.
Let us learn from the example of Simon Peter and the lesson of our Lord Jesus, neither to strive for nor rely upon the power and the glory of this world with its stats and its dollar signs, its popularity, prestige, and competitive comparisons, but to receive and bear the Cross that our Lord lays upon us in the hope and confidence of His Word and promises, in faith toward Him and in fervent love for one another. For as we suffer with Him, according to our calling, so shall we be glorified with Him, according to His grace.
